By Michelle Carr
I often find that the words come easiest to me when I feel a strong need to express myself. Yet sometimes even though I have all of the words, a topic still isn’t easy to express. This is one of those times. But this matter has weighed heavily on my heart for a long time and seeing the escalation of a certain movements, I feel once again that I need to speak out. This is a matter of hate and oppression.
So the 411 on myself, for those who do not know, I’m a blonde, blue eyed, typical looking Caucasian. The only types of oppression I have ever felt had to deal with are my age, gender and well my stances at times. But personally, I have had it far easier than a lot of people have, so I’m not here to talk about my issues. I do, however, have a strong sense of empathy for others and their pain. I can’t fully tell you why or what makes me different from those who don’t understand why people are still hurting. Maybe it’s because I starting reading books like Gone with the Wind in grade school for pleasure. Maybe it’s because the lessons I chose to keep from church were that of love everyone and to treat others with compassion as Jesus would do. Maybe it’s because as a writer and avid reader, I dive into characters, I become them. I feel what they feel and experience what they experience. So when someone tells me how they’ve been mistreated I literally imagine myself as them and how badly it must hurt to have gone through such things. Because of such, I am continuously baffled by those who continue to spread such hate. I find myself in utter disbelief when people tell me that I’m a bigot (and many other unsavory names) because I don’t support their unacceptance of others and that I need to change my point of view. But here is my truth, I will never see what I do as simply being politically correct. I see it as treating others with respect and not judging them on whom they love, what they look like, what gender they identify with, or how they do or do not worship. These characteristics are who they are and don’t hurt anyone else so why are others so concerned with them? I strive to spread love and have compassion for fellow humans and I will choose that over hate EVERY DAY.
Charlottesville’s tragedy has made my heart ache terribly. And sadly with most of our red state television’s tuned into one news station, I don’t believe many know the real story. They only see the spin that some would have you believe. But did you know it all started because Charlottesville’s City Council voted in favor of removing the Robert E Lee statue? But that there were some that were using a bill written in 1998 that forbids local government from removing, damaging or defacing war monuments. There has been some debate on the ambiguity of this bill and whether it applies to the Lee statue since it was clearly written after the statue was built. So the Judge issued an injunction preventing the removal of the Lee Statue until the lawsuit played out. A group of white-nationalists decided they were going to protest the City Council’s decision in what they called a “Unite the Right” rally. (Let that name …sink… in) Come the evening of August 11th two groups of anti-protestors of the Unite the Right formed. One group met inside a church to hold a meeting of peace and love. The second group surrounded the Lee Statue. The alt-right activists now came into the picture carrying torches. They crossed the campus and surrounded the church. This type of intimidation was all too often used in the past and terrified the people inside. The protestors chanted outside of the church “One people, one nation end immigration.” The frightened people inside the church were kept inside for their protection by the police and they began tweeting to those on the outside. One of the alt- right marchers tweeted out too and is recorded in this article. https://www.google.com/amp/metro.co.uk/2017/08/12/white-supremacists-carrying-torches-surround-church-during-alt-right-rally-6847162/amp/
“Don’t make the white kids angry. #UniteTheRight #Charlottesville.”
The Unite the Right protestors also surrounded those who had gathered at the Lee statue and screamed at them repeatedly that “White Lives Matter!” None of the many reports I have read gave tell of the anti-protestors taking violent action against the alt-right unless it was in a defensive move. But I have read and seen many accounts of weekend and it was the alt-right that were the aggressors each time. It was the alt- right that pushed, tripped and kicked a Unicorn Riot reporter. It was a man from the alt- right that walked up to an anti- protester pulled out his gun, tried to fire at him point blank andrealized he didn’t have a bullet in the chamber. I watched him fix his gun, aim again lower this time at the anti-protestor and fire. This was done in front of police who failed to stop the man who fired his weapon. Another witness caught on video a young man of dark skin who happened to appear at the wrong place at the wrong time. It looked like it was a parking garage full of alt-righters who carried shields and weapons and who were dressed in armor. The cowards attacked this young man who only carried a backpack on his back. They beat him with shields and weapons, knocking him to the ground and attacking him all together at once. He managed to get up, blooded and tried to run away before he fell down and was pounced upon again. I dare you to tell me that this young unarmed boy was that much of a threat to this twenty or more group of armed protected cowards.
The most known about act of the weekend happened during a peaceful march. The anti-protestors were marching, some were in the street. (I am not sure if they were crossing or marching the street. Sometimes street marching is permitted.) A man drove a car through the people and plowed into the line of cars that had been moving slowly with the group. This caused a chain reaction; making cars to hit the cars in front of them, squash and hit pedestrians, as well as throwing some into the air. The driver reversed out as quickly as he had driven in. This action injured a dozen marchers and killed Heather Heyer. The man arrested for the crime is an alt-right supporter. The facts are very clear on who the aggressors were during this weekend. Even the Mayor himself expressed that he was seeing a parade of hatred, bigotry, racism and intolerance march down the lawns of the architect of our Bill of Rights. With all the acts of violence this “Unite the Right” rally was deemed unlawful at one point and yet the people continued to violate the orders to cease. Many warrants were issued for the original ralliers including the man who allegedly drove the car.
Now the kicker of all of this is that even though the facts clearly show what happened that weekend, Trump (current occupier of the White House) made three very odd and kind of confusing speeches. During the first speech he tipped toed around what was obviously clear, that these aggressive actions were crimes of hate perpetrated by the alt- right. He declared there was “good people on both sides”. So to clarify, some people marching, chanting hate chants, and working with the white supremacists, KKK and Neo- Nazis were “Good People”. People carrying flags with Nazi symbols and heiling could have been “Good People” that were just what … misunderstood? Me thinks they knew exactly what they were doing and meant every moment of it. This first speech well, it received a lot of criticism from a lot of people. But do you know who didn’t criticize it… the leader of the white nationalist group. He spoke highly of the speech and encouraged his people to carry on because Trump didn’t reprimand them so it gives them permission. So now came the second speech. In this speech, Trump changed his tone ever so slightly. Now, to save face, he lightly smacked the alt- right on the hands. He called out the three groups and said we won’t take this in America. This speech gave some a feeling of comfort. Those like me knew better. The white nationalist leader, now begged Trump in tweets to not cave into the Liberals. Don’t let the Liberals tell you what to say and the real kicker of this was the reminder he gave Trump to remember who voted you into office. Now came the third speech in which Trump began to blame the alt- left for the violence. He was like a child complaining that he thought he said everything in his apology that he was supposed to and why oh why am I still being punished? With the blame shifted, the alt-right went back to work planning almost a dozen more rallies. Now they called them “Freedom of Speech” rallies. And when they were clearly outnumbered by peaceful anti-protesters they hid in gazebos and whined about how frightened they were. (Giant eye roll) Now because of all of this the United Nations sent America a warning that we are showing signs of heading to a civil war. The UNITED NATIONS. Sent a warning the kind that usually goes out to under developed countries as they struggle to set leadership. Think about that. http://shareblue.com/trumps-violent-racism-disgraces-america-earns-rare-early-warning-from-united-nations/
A shift has begun to happen, more and more people are taking Trump’s argument that the Confederate statues are a part of our history and shouldn’t be touched. (Deep Breath) I am all too familiar with historians and other such writers of important work (Men who wrote the Bible) who conveniently left out or lessened the roles of some people in their retelling. So I firmly believe history should be maintained accurately. We can’t learn from the past if we don’t know how it truly happened. (MASSIVE BUT) The removal of the Confederate statues is not erasing history. They have no place being on school campuses, public parks or in town squares to be glorified as heroes. They fought on the side that pulled out of our country, sought to continue to enslave humans in efforts to better themselves and oh yea they LOST. Their roles will never be forgotten. If the statues are wanted, put them in a museum so those who want to see them can. But don’t leave them out as a daily reminder to some the how horrific we were to their ancestors. Don’t glorify a person who if they had won would’ve kept people in chains longer than they already were. I don’t know what side my ancestors were on during this war. But I can tell you that some of my blood is Native American and I would not tolerate walking by a statue of Custard every day. And think about it, would you be comfortable if it was a Hitler statue? No? Then why should we protect these when the Nazis clearly think it’s so important?
Tell me why is the preservation of Confederate Statues more of a concern for Trump than preserving our National Monuments. Secretary Zinke has announced he is going to cut back on the size of our National Monuments so they can retrieve fossil fuels from them. So statues of losing generals yes… protecting the Grand Canyon… no. Protecting the Sioux Nations Sacred lands from a leaking pipeline is not worry at all either. But by golly save that statue…I don’t know about you, but I would much rather my children see such places like the Grand Canyon fully intact than to go visit the statue of Robert E Lee.
I found myself, days later, taking a stand against those who took a leap saying that the pride flag was just as offensive as the confederate flag and shouldn’t be allowed. Some tried to tell me that I didn’t like things flipping back on me since I am a Liberal. Like anyone who stands for the removal of a Confederate statue or flag could possibly compare to a person just not liking to see a pride flag because their religion tells them not to. One of these things is so not like the other. One clearly stands for the side who fought to enslave others and is carried by those who use it as an excuse to hate on people. The other is a symbol of love and the pride in finally being able to express it. What bothered me the most in my attempt to discuss this topic with those who didn’t agree with my stance, was when I was told that “Trump doesn’t do politically correct and this is why we elected him.” And told that I should “Get over it and correct myself.”
So once again I say being politically correct is not some fake act. It is treating others as you yourself would want to be treated. Some of you should remember that when you are holding your christian flag and screaming about the pride flag that signifies love and acceptance. Try practicing the compassion some of you were taught in church. Because I’m not seeing it used by those who claim the loudest to be holier than thou. I ask myself often where is the compassion for other humans? Where is the common sense? Because if you feel this fight in Charlottesville was really about preserving history then are you also fighting to save the Scared Lands of the Sioux Nation? Bear Ears? Or the Grand Canyon? If you’re not, then you should be asking yourself why? Are you more concerned over a slab of metal shaped into a fallible human than you are over land we can never get back once it’s destroyed? If your answer is yes than my friend your fight has nothing to do with preserving history and you need to rethink your argument. Ask yourself if you feel good that you are taking the side that the KKK, Neo-Nazi and White supremacists chose? Because that is not a side I would ever want to find myself on. And I’m telling you straight up, we are never ever going to begin to heal these wounds that were inflicted, if we continue to glorify the wrong things. We will never be able to unify, unless we all begin to show compassion for one another as people.
The hope, I carry with me through all of this, comes from the reminder that there were three million more of us on this end to begin with. I find strength from all the beautiful souls I meet every day who are working to keep this country from stepping back into the age of darkness. People who fight for each other and for our future as a country. The future of our world. People who show and spread love every single day. Because in the end, couldn’t we all stand to LOVE MORE?
Other sources: